Closing the Exposure Gap
How Safetyism Is Quietly Making Us Weaker
It begins with a bridge.
Not a metaphorical one—though that’s coming—but an actual steel and suspension bridge, slick from morning rain, stretching across a cold river in Vancouver. On one side: a nervous young student in a psychology experiment. On the other: the unknown.
The researcher doesn’t shove them. He doesn’t coax. He simply asks them to cross.
Half of them walk across. Half don’t. The ones who cross leave with more than just a data point—they leave with a changed nervous system, a body that has just whispered to itself: I can do hard things.
This is exposure in its purest form. And in today’s world, it’s becoming endangered.
The Age of Safetyism
We live in an era obsessed with safety.
Padded playgrounds. Helicopter parenting. Warning labels on coffee cups.
What started as sensible caution has metastasized into something else entirely: safetyism—the belief that eliminating every possible risk is the highest good.
It sounds noble. But in our effort to protect ourselves from harm, we may be dismantling the very systems that make us strong.
Neuroscience tells us something uncomfortable: controlled exposure to discomfort, uncertainty, and even fear is essential. It is the gym where our resilience is trained. Without it, the muscles of courage atrophy.
The Exposure Gap
The Exposure Gap is the growing distance between the challenges we think we can handle and the challenges real life will inevitably hand us.
The wider the gap, the more fragile we become.
The narrower the gap, the more adaptable we are.
This isn’t theoretical. Studies show that avoidance of small stressors—cold, public speaking, difficult conversations—makes us less able to cope when real adversity arrives.
And the most dangerous part? The Exposure Gap doesn’t announce itself.
You don’t see it forming. You only discover it in the moment you need resilience the most…
And that’s where the trouble begins.
Because once the Exposure Gap is wide enough, even ordinary challenges can feel impossible.
In the rest of this piece, I’ll show you:
Why safetyism is rewiring your brain in ways you can’t feel—yet.
The surprising psychological experiments that prove discomfort is your best training ground.
A 4-step “Bridge Crossing Plan” for shrinking your own Exposure Gap—starting today.
But first, let’s go back to that student on the bridge in Vancouver. Because what happened next reveals the real cost of comfort…
The Rest of the Story
The student takes a tentative first step. The bridge sways—just slightly—but enough to remind them that the world beneath is very, very far away.
By the time they reach the other side, something strange has happened: their heart rate has slowed. Their breathing has steadied. And when the researcher hands them a follow-up questionnaire, their answers are more confident, more open.
Later analysis will show that students who crossed the bridge weren’t just braver in that moment—they were braver in the next challenge, too.
Exposure, it turns out, compounds.
Why Your Brain Needs Discomfort
From a neuroscience standpoint, controlled exposure rewires the brain in two crucial ways:
Amygdala calibration – The amygdala is your fear alarm. Exposure helps tune it so it doesn’t overreact to non-lethal threats (like giving a speech).
Prefrontal cortex engagement – This “executive” part of the brain learns to override emotional panic, allowing you to think clearly under stress.
Without regular training, both systems get sloppy. Your amygdala rings at the wrong times. Your prefrontal cortex fumbles. The result? Everyday stressors start to feel like existential threats.
How Safetyism Creates the Exposure Gap
Every time we bubble-wrap our lives—skipping the hard conversation, avoiding the physical challenge, outsourcing the scary decision—we reinforce one idea: You can’t handle this.
Multiply that over years, and you get the Exposure Gap: a chasm between what you’ve experienced and what you’ll eventually have to face.
This is why young adults who have been spared from discomfort often collapse under the weight of their first real crisis. It’s not because they’re weak—it’s because their nervous system has never been trained for turbulence.
Shrinking the Gap: The Bridge Crossing Plan
You can’t eliminate risk, nor should you. But you can build a practice of intentional exposure so your resilience is ready when you need it most.
Step 1 – Identify Your Avoidance Zones
Make a short list of the situations you tend to sidestep—anything from speaking up in a meeting to taking a cold shower.
Step 2 – Dose, Don’t Drown
Start with exposures small enough to feel uncomfortable, but not paralyzing. Think of it like weight training: you want challenge, not injury.
Step 3 – Anchor the Wins
After each exposure, reflect on what you just proved to yourself. Write it down. This helps your brain encode the victory.
Step 4 – Stack the Challenges
Gradually increase intensity. Small wins become bigger wins, and your nervous system adapts to higher levels of uncertainty.
The Real Lesson of the Bridge
The bridge in Vancouver is just a metaphor for all the crossings you’ll face in life. Illness. Job loss. A relationship ending. A chance worth taking.
If you’ve built your courage muscle through regular exposure, those crossings will still be scary—but they won’t be impossible.
Because here’s the quiet truth:
Resilience isn’t built in the moment you need it. It’s built in every small, uncomfortable step you take before then.
Call to Action:
This week, pick one thing you’ve been avoiding. Cross your own bridge—no matter how small—and close your Exposure Gap before life forces you to.
— John
Listen to the full ad-free episode below.